Homemade Marinara Sauce

This recipe for Homemade Marinara Sauce is a rich tomato based sauce full of traditional marinara ingredients: fresh basil, spices, garlic, onions, flavorful tomatoes, and herb flavored extra virgin olive oil. It tastes like it simmered in your Grandma’s kitchen all day.

It is perfect over pasta or used in any of your favorite recipes that call for marinara or tomato sauce.

I add a few unique ingredients to make sure my Homemade Marinara Sauce has the best flavor.

The addition of balsamic vinegar adds a warm flavor in the background. A little sugar balances the acidity of the  vinegar. The unexpected ingredient of evaporated milk adds just a hint of creaminess without making it a “cream sauce”, it also soothes the acidity of the tomatoes.

Easy Homemade Marinara Sauce Ingredients

Cento Crushed Tomatoes

Since tomatoes are the star of this recipe, I recommend buying the very best canned tomatoes you can.

I prefer to use Cento Crushed Tomatoes, they are a super high quality canned tomato product. Cento Crushed Tomatoes are grown in California, abiding to the high quality standards of the Cento company. Resulting in a super flavorful, rich tomato product.

If you want to have an authentic Italian grown tomato you could also choose to use Cento’s Organic Crushed Tomatoes or Whole Peeled San Marzano Tomatoes. Both of these products are grown in Italy.  However, only the Whole Peeled Tomatoes follow the strict guidelines that come with being Certified San Marzano.

Also great to note that all Cento products are canned in non-BPA cans and are 100% recyclable.

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Using a good extra virgin olive oil is also key in this recipe. You do not want to use plain olive oil, it will not give you the same flavor. Extra Virgin Olive Oil is the one that has intense, rich, buttery olive flavor that you can truly taste.

My favorite EVOO, Organic Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Aldi, has such an intense flavor that it is almost spicy! You can pick it up at Aldi for around $4.00 a bottle. It is a great fit for this Homemade Marinara Sauce recipe because the EVOO flavor compliments Cento’s rich tomato flavor perfectly.

Fresh Herbs

Fresh rosemary and basil add a beautiful herbaceous flavor to this Marinara. They are fried in the EVOO, releasing all their flavor into the oil, which is then infused into the entire pot of sauce. The fried herbs are discarded and then the remaining basil gets chopped and added to the sauce. Lending the perfect Italian flavors.

Evaporated Milk

There is one unusual ingredient that I add, evaporated milk. I do this to create an almost creamy texture and taste to the marinara. It is not the same as adding half and half or heavy whipping cream, that would turn this recipe into a true cream sauce.

The evaporated milk just mellows the acidity and gives it a velvety flavor. You can also simmer the evaporated milk without worrying it will curdle.

How to Make Easy Homemade Marinara Sauce

I love how you start this recipe, by frying the fresh rosemary and 6 basil leaves in the extra virgin olive oil. It is such a simple step but makes such a difference in the flavor of your Homemade Marinara!

When the herbs start to get crispy, about 5 minutes, you will pull the herbs out and discard. Some pieces may crumble off into the oil, that is ok, but try to get the majority of the herb solids out of the oil.

In the now fragrant oil, add the onions and garlic and saute over medium low heat for about 5 minutes until the onions are softened.

Next you will add all the remaining ingredients: fresh basil, Cento Crushed Tomatoes, onion powder, dried oregano, salt, sugar, pinch of red pepper flakes, balsamic vinegar, and evaporated milk. Stir everything so it is well combined, place the lid on the pot and simmer over medium low heat for 20 minutes. You will want to stir the sauce occasionally to make sure the tomatoes do not burn on the bottom.

Once the tomato sauce is ready taste for seasoning (salt and pepper) and pour over your warm pasta.

You can also make this Homemade Marinara Sauce ahead and store in the fridge for use during a busy week. Let the sauce cool for about 25-30 minutes and then place in an airtight container in the fridge for 4-5 days. You may need to thin the sauce with ¼ cup of water when reheating.

Making Easy Homemade Marinara Sauce Your Own

We love this recipe just as is, but it is easily customizable to suit your family’s taste buds. Here are a few ideas:

• After the sauce is cooked stir in cooked and drained ground beef or ground Italian sausage for a meat sauce.
• If you like your sauce spicy add more than a pinch of red pepper flakes.
• Make this a true tomato cream sauce by adding ⅓ cup of heavy whipping cream after it is done simmering.
• Use this sauce as a sub in your favorite recipes calling for marinara.
• If you want an authentic San Marzano tomato flavor, use the Cento Whole Peeled Tomatoes. Just crush them by hand before adding them to the pot.

Easy Homemade Marinara Sauce & Pasta for Dinner

Like I said before this is a tear free dinner at our house, so it is a Mom’s Dinner favorite! This Homemade Marinara Sauce gets spooned over spaghetti or penne and garnished with Parmesan cheese, red pepper flakes, fresh basil, or all three.

On a busy night it is served with an easy to make bagged Caesar salad. On the weekend when we have a little more time to prep dinner and sit around the table I will add my lemon garlic green beans and garlic bread.

More Italian Style Recipes

If you like this recipe, you may also want to check out these recipes on Mom’s Dinner:

• Instant Pot Sausage Rigatoni with Tomato Cream Sauce
• Goat Cheese Pizza with Sun Dried Tomatoes & Pine Nuts
• Lasagna Roll Ups
• Instant Pot Beef & Barley Soup with Pistou

Originally Posted May 2018 – Copy Updated March 2020