Our Favorite Chicken Enchilada Recipe

My Homemade Chicken Enchilada Recipe is full of tender chicken, garlic, red onions, cilantro and cheese. The outside is warm and flavorful with lots of red enchilada sauce, ooey gooey cheese, and fresh green onions.

Chicken Enchiladas for dinner is a favorite at our house. If I had to only eat one thing for the rest of my life Enchiladas would be a hard contender! 

If you love them as much as me, also check out these recipes for veggie enchiladas, beef enchilada casserole, and enchilada zucchini boats.

How to Cook Chicken Breasts for Enchiladas

There are a few ways that I recommend cooking your chicken for enchiladas.

1. Buying a rotisserie chicken is the easiest way, and probably my preferred method (You can make your own rotisserie chicken in the Instant Pot!). Shred both breasts, discarding the skin. You end up with super juicy and tender chicken.
2. Poaching the chicken breasts is my second preferred method. This is great if you do not have time to grab a rotisserie chicken.
3. If you have an instant pot, this is a really quick way to cook your chicken for shredding or chopping. You can find the recipe and instructions for Instant Pot All Purpose Shredded Chicken here.

Enchilada Sauce

If you want to make your own red chili sauce this is our go-to recipe that makes about 2 cups of sauce. It can be made ahead, doubled, tripled and even frozen for later use: Homemade Red Enchilada Sauce Recipe

How to Make My Chicken Enchilada Recipe

Start by preheating your oven to 350°.

In a large sauté pan cook the garlic and red or white onions in oil over medium heat until the onions become slightly translucent, about 5 minutes.

Then you will add your cooked, shredded or chopped chicken, cilantro, ⅓ cup enchilada sauce and all the spices/seasonings. Stir the mixture until the chicken is coated with all the seasonings and sauce.

Pour the remaining ⅔ can of enchilada sauce in the bottom of a 9×13 glass baking dish.

Now it is time to assemble the Chicken Enchiladas. Lay everything out in an assembly line to make rolling the enchiladas go a little faster. You will have:

• Tortillas
• Chicken mixture
• 1 cup of shredded cheese
• Prepared 9×13 pan

Lay a couple spoonfuls of the chicken mixture down the center of the tortilla. Sprinkle the chicken with a pinch or two of cheese. Now roll the tortilla over the chicken mixture, like rolling a cigar.

Lay the filled tortilla seam side down in the prepared 9×13 glass baking dish. To fit all 10-12 enchiladas you may have to fit a couple in the side. See the picture below:

Once the pan is filled pour the remaining can of enchilada sauce evenly over the top of the enchiladas. If you like your enchiladas super saucy, you can use an extra can of enchilada sauce poured over top.

Sprinkle the remaining cup of cheese and finish with all the green onions.

Cover the pan with foil and bake at 350° for 25 minutes. Then remove the foil and bake for an additional 10 minutes until the cheese is melted and the sauce is bubbly.

Let the Chicken Enchiladas cool for about 5 minutes before serving.

Flour Tortilla vs. Corn Tortilla for Chicken Enchiladas

This really depends on your personal preference. It is more traditional to use corn tortillas in your enchiladas. But, I find that sometimes they can be hard to work with. They are very temperamental and crack and tear easily.

Flour tortillas (fajita size) are much easier to work with, but you will be missing the extra flavor of corn. However, I do love the texture of the flour tortillas after they have soaked and baked in the enchilada sauce. They become soft and almost buttery.

So it’s really a toss up. I say if you have the patience- use corn. If all you have is flour tortillas- use flour. Keep it simple and don’t stress about these little things! This recipe will turn out whether you use flour or corn… because this Chicken Enchilada recipe is THAT delicious.

Variations on Chicken Enchiladas

Here are a few ideas to change up this Chicken Enchilada recipe to make it your own:

• Add black beans to the chicken mixture for a little more protein.
• Try using ground beef instead of chicken.
• Use whatever cheese you have on hand. Monterey Jack, Colby Jack, Mexican Blend, Cheddar, or Pepper Jack would all work just fine.
• Corn Tortillas or Flour Tortillas, use whatever you have or whatever you prefer.
• If you want some heat add a few pinches of cayenne pepper or red pepper flakes to the chicken mixture.
• Try using Green Enchilada Sauce for a Verde Chicken Enchilada.

What Goes Well with Chicken Enchiladas for Dinner

This is one of my favorite dinners. I keep the sides pretty simple! I like to serve my enchiladas with my Easy 15-Minute Refried Beans and Mexican Rice.

Don’t forget the drinks, a Margarita, Mexican Mule or Rosemary Paloma are the perfect pick, & Restaurant Style Salsa with chips is always good!

---